Share Article
October 21, 2024
HR Tech: Navigating The Maze of Options - Is A Spreadsheet Really The Answer
As businesses evolve and embrace digital solutions, one area that has seen rapid innovation is Human Resources. From managing employee records to tracking performance, HR technology promises to simplify and streamline processes. However, with so many options available, many HR professionals are left asking, "Which one is right for us?" And for some, the question remains—is a spreadsheet really the answer?
We’ve been speaking to our HR clients recently, and the consensus seems to be that navigating the HR tech landscape is a minefield. Some solutions focus on one key area, while others aim to cover the entire employee lifecycle. The result? It can be difficult to know where to start.
The Abundance of HR Software Options
In today’s market, there are countless HR systems, each offering its own set of tools and benefits. Some of the most popular HR software solutions include:
- Breathe HR: Perfect for small and medium-sized businesses, Breathe HR offers a simple, user-friendly platform that focuses on core HR functions like managing employee data, absence tracking, and performance management. However, for those seeking more specialized features like recruitment or payroll, it may not be the most comprehensive option.
- Hi Bob: A newer platform making waves, Hi Bob combines employee engagement tools with core HR features. It’s ideal for growing businesses looking for a fresh approach to HR tech, offering features like people analytics and culture mapping, but some users have found it more geared toward employee experience rather than administration-heavy HR tasks.
- Bright HR: Another favorite among SMEs, Bright HR helps businesses manage leave, expenses, and even health and safety, offering a full toolkit for compliance and HR management. However, if you’re looking for advanced recruitment or learning and development features, it may not cover all the bases.
- BambooHR: Known for its easy-to-use interface, BambooHR focuses on employee data management, time-off tracking, and performance management. However, it doesn’t offer in-depth payroll features.
- Workday: A robust system offering everything from HR management to finance and planning, but its complexity may overwhelm smaller businesses looking for simplicity.
- Personio: Aimed at SMEs, Personio combines recruiting, employee data, payroll, and more, but users have mentioned that its recruiting features are more advanced than its HR administration tools.
- SAP SuccessFactors: A comprehensive suite for large enterprises, it covers everything from recruitment to employee engagement. However, with so many features, the learning curve can be steep for smaller teams.
Each of these platforms offers significant benefits, but they don’t all solve the same problems. If you're looking to improve recruitment and onboarding, one solution might be perfect for you. But if your focus is on employee development and performance, another might be the better fit. This is where many HR managers feel stuck.
Can a Spreadsheet Compete?
With so many HR tech choices, some businesses—especially SMEs—still rely on spreadsheets to track employee data. It’s a solution that offers simplicity and flexibility, but is it really the answer for modern HR needs?
Spreadsheets may work for small teams with straightforward HR processes, but they lack scalability, automation, and integration. When it comes to managing complex tasks like payroll, performance reviews, and compliance, manual entry in a spreadsheet opens the door to errors, inefficiencies, and lost time. As one HR manager told us, “We thought we were saving money by sticking with spreadsheets, but the time spent fixing mistakes far outweighed any savings.”
What Should You Look For?
When choosing HR software, it’s important to start with your specific needs. Do you want to focus on recruitment and onboarding? Or are you looking to improve employee engagement and retention?
Once you’ve identified your priorities, here are a few key questions to consider:
- Integration: Does the software integrate with your current tools, such as payroll systems or recruitment platforms?
- User-friendliness: Is it intuitive and easy for both HR staff and employees to use?
- Scalability: Will it grow with your business, or will you outgrow it in a few years?
- Support and training: What level of support is offered? Will you and your team get the training you need to fully utilize the platform?
The Verdict: One Size Does Not Fit All
The HR tech landscape is indeed a minefield, with solutions that focus on every aspect of the employee lifecycle. While no single system will fit every business perfectly, choosing the right one requires a balance between your unique needs and the platform’s capabilities. Spreadsheets might work in the short term, but as your business grows, relying on manual tools could become a costly and time-consuming mistake.
If you’re feeling overwhelmed by the options, know that you’re not alone. We've helped many clients navigate this decision-making process, and we’d be happy to help you too. Whether you need guidance on where to start or are looking for a solution that integrates seamlessly with your current processes, we’re here to ensure you make the right choice for your business.
A practical guide to salary reviews in 2026. Understand pay structures, National Living Wage impacts, benchmarking, and how to avoid inconsistency.
Statutory Sick Pay, maternity pay and payroll thresholds increase from April 2026. See the new SSP rates, family leave payments, Lower Earnings Limit and what UK employers must update now.
UK National Minimum Wage and National Living Wage rise in April 2026. Check the new hourly rates, payroll cost impact, common compliance risks and what employers must do now to stay compliant.
Small Business UK Employment Law Checklist 2026. Review contracts, SSP, flexible working, harassment duties, ACAS compliance and minimum wage updates to reduce legal risk.
How to prevent workplace sexual harassment under UK law. Understand the strengthened preventative duty, “all reasonable steps” requirement, third-party risk and employer compliance in 2026.
Flexible working rules explained for UK employers. Learn day-one request rights, the two-request rule, consultation requirements, statutory refusal grounds and 2026 compliance risks.
Avoid common UK employment law mistakes that lead to costly disputes. A practical guide for SMEs covering contracts, holiday pay, SSP changes, flexible working, probation, redundancy rules and 2026 updates.
Small and medium employers are used to juggling checklists. Payroll, recruitment, line-manager training, etc. But 2026 is different: the rules aren’t just changing, and the way decisions are judged is shifting. That makes everyday choices (flexible-working replies, sickness pay, probation calls) more likely to land a business in trouble, even when managers act in good faith. Below are the practical changes UK SMEs should prioritise now, what they mean in everyday terms, and a short checklist you can action this week. Quick summary From 6 April 2026 , some family and sick-pay rights become day-one entitlements. That affects paternity, unpaid parental leave and statutory sick pay. Statutory Sick Pay (SSP) waiting days are being removed and entitlement rules change — payroll must be ready. Collective redundancy penalties increase: protective awards can double, so consult properly or risk larger fines. These changes are rolling in across 2026; employers should focus on process, documentation and manager training , not just policy wording. What’s changing (and why it matters) 1. Day-one family rights — paternity & unpaid parental leave From April 2026, employees can give notice for statutory paternity leave and unpaid parental leave from their first day of employment. That removes the old 26-week / 12-month service tests and brings more people into scope immediately, which is good for families, but means employers must be ready to process, record and respond to requests from day one. Practical impact: update your parental-leave procedure, train whoever handles returns and leave, and make sure your contractual templates and employee handbook reflect the new eligibility rules. 2. Statutory Sick Pay: waiting days gone, wider entitlement The current three waiting-day rule for SSP is being removed from 6 April 2026, and entitlement rules are being widened (for example, the lower earnings threshold is being removed). SSP rates are also updated for 2026–27. Payroll teams need to be able to pay SSP from day one and to calculate linked periods correctly. Practical impact: talk to payroll/your software provider now. Test scenarios: short absences, linked periods, low-paid staff. Confirm how your payroll will apply the new SSP rules from 6 April. 3. Redundancy and collective consultation: higher protective awards The maximum protective award for failing to consult properly in a collective redundancy situation will increase (reports indicate a doubling to 180 days’ pay). That makes getting consultation, records and redundancy planning right far more important. Practical impact: audit your redundancy playbook, update consultation steps, and ensure you have a clear paper trail showing how decisions were reached and who was consulted. 4. The broader shift: process matters more than ever Across the Employment Rights Act and related reforms, a repeated theme is that tribunals and regulators are looking for defensible processes: consistent handling, documented reasoning and fair communication. That means the smallest missing note in a file, an informal chat that wasn’t recorded, or inconsistent treatment of similar cases can be costly. Practical impact: build manager scripts, standard templates for decisions, and a simple central filing system for HR notes. Train managers to log reasoning, not just outcomes. What SMEs should do this week (practical checklist) Immediate (this week) Talk to payroll: confirm SSP changes will be applied from 6 April 2026 and test a Day-1 absence scenario. Update your parental-leave and paternity-leave procedure to reflect day-one entitlement. Put a ‘how to’ note in the employee handbook and your manager guidance. Identify who handles redundancy consultation and map the steps — confirm who will lead and document each stage. Short term (2–4 weeks) Run a 30-minute manager briefing: how to record decision reasoning, where to save notes, how to respond to flexible-working and SSP queries. (Make it practical, use examples.) Review and update contract templates and staff handbook sections that reference qualifying periods, waiting days or eligibility tests. If you have uncertainties Keep a short list of questions and seek a 15-minute HR/ employment-law clinic rather than overhauling everything at once. Many small fixes (clear wording, a consistent file note template, payroll checks) remove most risk. FAQs Q: Do I have to update every contract before 6 April? A: Not always. Prioritise payroll and policies for SSP and parental rights, and ensure your core contract wording doesn’t contradict the new rules. Plan a phased update for full contract refresh. Q: What happens if I get it wrong? A: For individual disputes, you might face claims (and back-pay for SSP). For collective redundancy failures, protective awards can be materially higher from April 2026, so weak process can be costly. Q: Should I panic and rewrite every policy now? A: No. Start with the high-risk items: payroll SSP, parental-leave eligibility, and redundancy consultation steps. Fix the data and the decision flow; wording and full rewrites can follow on a schedule. Want a hand? If you’d rather not puzzle through the detail alone, we’re running a short, practical webinar that covers these exact points and gives you an immediate checklist to act on. Learn more about it here.
Practical insights to improve offer acceptance and avoid costly delays
If you’ve recruited over the last year or two and found yourself thinking “it never used to be this difficult”, you’re not alone. Between us, Emma and I have spent over three decades working alongside SME business owners, and one thing is clear – recruitment hasn’t suddenly broken, but the way people find, choose and commit to jobs has changed significantly. What used to work on autopilot now needs thought, planning and consistency. The market has shifted – and candidates know it Good candidates are more selective than ever. They’re not just looking at the job, they’re looking at the business behind it. How clear the role is, how quickly decisions are made, and how the opportunity compares to what else is out there all play a part. For SMEs, this can feel uncomfortable. Larger businesses may have brand recognition or bigger budgets, but SMEs often underestimate their own strengths – culture, flexibility, visibility and access to decision-makers – which are hugely attractive when positioned properly. Recruitment works best when you have a river of talent, not a tap One of the biggest challenges we see is businesses only recruiting when they have to. A resignation lands, pressure builds, and recruitment becomes reactive. The businesses that recruit most successfully tend to do the opposite. They are always keeping an eye on the market, always having conversations, and always building a small but steady river of potential talent – even when there isn’t an immediate vacancy. This doesn’t mean constant advertising. It means being visible, knowing who you want to attract, and having a plan for how you’ll engage people when the timing is right. Planning and competitor awareness make a real difference SMEs don’t need to outspend their competitors, but they do need to understand them. Knowing what similar businesses are offering, how roles are being positioned, and where salaries and benefits sit gives you clarity and confidence when you do go to market. It also helps avoid wasted time chasing candidates who were never likely to move. Clear planning upfront – role scope, priorities, budget and decision-making timescales – saves weeks later in the process. A few practical ways SMEs can attract better candidates From our experience, a handful of small adjustments can make a big difference. Being clear about who you want to attract and why they’d choose you. Moving quickly once you meet the right person. Communicating well and keeping candidates informed. And presenting your business honestly and confidently, rather than underselling what you offer. Recruitment isn’t about perfection – it’s about clarity and consistency. Getting back to confident, effective hiring Recruitment will always take time and effort, particularly for SMEs wearing multiple hats. But with the right planning, a steady pipeline of talent and a realistic view of the market, it becomes far more manageable – and far more successful. Good candidates are still out there. The key is knowing who you want, staying visible, and being ready when the right person appears.